It
was Will Durant (and NOT Aristotle) who said “We are what we repeatedly do.
Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit” in his book, “The Story of
Philosophy”.
If
you add to the foregoing nugget of wisdom,
the divine revelation in verse 148 of Surah Baqarah, “fastabiqul
khairaat aina maa takoonoo ya’ti bikumullaahu jamee’an.” (then strive together
(as in a race) Towards all that is good. Wheresoever you are, Allah will bring
you Together); then you would agree with me that raising the bar from our
abysmal low in this country, and to strive to maintain high #standards becomes
a religious obligation.
In
a letter published by the Standard newspaper, Thursday March 12, 2020, written
by one Yankuba Jallow, claiming to be a final year law student at the UTG, I
was vilified and pilloried in the most unjust manner.
The
writer attacked me under the caption “No person or authority can shut down TRRC
Letter to Momodou Sabally” in response to a whatsap audio message that never
mentioned my name as the creator of that message. The whole episode reminded me
of the very first stanza from Bob Marley’s song “Stiff Necked Fools”:
Stiff-necked fools, you think you are cool... Yes, you have got the wrong
interpretation. Mixed up with vain imagination!
In
fact more than a week before the publication of this malicious letter by the
Standard, I had published a whatsap audio message dissociating myself from the
said audio. A Mentee of mine suggested that I publish the same disclaimer on
Facebook in text form; which I promptly did so that it became clear the audio
referred to by Mr. Jallow and many others, was not mine. I went further to
clarify that any audio made my me comes with my vocal signature at the
beginning and end of the message.
But
some Gambians are interesting beings. I must admit that Mr. Jallow was not
alone in the attacks launched against me regarding the audio. Many people
called friends to vilify me without any evidence that the said audio was made
by me. A man claiming to be a follower of the Ahmadiyya religious order
actually insulted me on Facebook for that audio. To his credit, he did
apologise when he found out that the audio was not from me.
As
for Mr. Jallow, his teachers need to ‘detain’ him at the university a bit
longer because if such a character is let lose into the legal profession, then
he might cause some unintended damage to the profession. For God’s sake, the
practice of law is based on the foundation of evidence. The business of law is
not one that is rooted in emotions and mere verbiage. The young man should take
more lessons or repeat a few. Where is the evidence that the audio he listened
to was made by Momodou Sabally?
I
have strong views on many issues including religion but I am the most
respectful of other people’s beliefs and opinions. I am not the one to force my
views down the throats of dissenting voices. I have adopted this attitude of
tolerance for religious reasons and not any malleable legal or ethical ethos
that is in flux due to human caprices. My Quran has taught me to be tolerant
and that I have no authority to condemn others or decide their fate.
Since
the author of the letter dwelled a lot on the TRRC, let me switch to that. For
the record, I am one of the first Gambians to criticise the set-up of the TRRC
and I still stand by my criticism of that institution. However, I have never
called for the banning or stopping of the TRRC and its proceedings. I am very
much sensitive to the plight of the victims and I believe that they have the
right to be heard.
My
criticism of the TRRC was based firstly on the disingenuous appointment of
Alhagie Saidy Barrow as Director of investigation because he is conflicted.
Thank God he has finally ‘recused’ himself from the proceedings of the
commission albeit not for any ethical reason.
Other
snide remarks I have launched at the TRRC include the suboptimal way in which
the Lead Counsel has been performing. I still stand by such criticism made on social media. First, the Lead Counsel was
wrong to have openly gifted a witness a piece of land even before other
relevant testimonies came in the matter that was at hand. I also made this
observation in an article:
When
the TRRC was being launched, ICC prosecutor Fatou Bom Bensouda was an invited
guest of honour and the whole country glossed over this. Now please read the
excerpt (below) as carefully and succinctly observed by journalists Mustapha K.
Darboe and Thierry Cruvellier on the website www.justiceinfo.net:
ESSA
FAAL’S CONVICTIONS AND PRUDENCE
When
on January 28 this year Batch Samba Jallow testified publicly before the TRRC
and implicated Fatou Bensouda, the Commission’s lead counsel, Essa Faal, seemed
caught off guard and embarrassed ... He is a key contributor to the success of
this justice process and the credibility of its investigations. He is also a
former ephemeral member of the State Prosecutor’s Office of The Gambia in 1994.
And more importantly he is a former colleague of Fatou Bensouda at the
International Criminal Court. At the hearing, the dialogue between the victim
and the lead counsel seemed to end in disagreement about the conclusions to be
drawn from Jallow’s experience.
–
“Who was the prosecutor in this case? asked Essa Faal.
–
Fatou Bensouda. She was the mastermind, replied Jallow.
–
Ah, she was the prosecutor.
–
Yes, she was the mastermind of everything we went through.
–
Ah… You would agree that Mrs Fatou Bensouda, if she was the prosecutor at all,
would have come at the tail end of things, at the prosecution stage of things
and therefore would not have participated in anything that happened before your
prosecution. Correct?
–
No, I don’t agree.”
It
did not take much longer for the suspicions to arise that preferential
treatment or protection may be given to the former personal legal adviser and
minister of Justice of Yahya Jammeh…
So
our Lead Counsel, who is well known for his toughness on witnesses, constantly
in attack mode, morphed into a de facto defence counsel when the subject was a
close associate of his. Could Essa Faal have taught our young lawyers a good
lesson in standards by recusing himself from that seat when close associates
like his former boss Bun Jack appeared before the TRRC?
But
despite all the aforementioned criticism, I never suggested the closure of the
TRRC. I was just speaking as a concerned Gambian who thought that we could have
operated on higher standards in our proceedings for the common good. The ‘mbojo
mbojo’ standard we have espoused in New Gambia is bad and not necessary. But
with emotions at their pinnacle during the first two years of this transition
some people simply attacked me for voicing my opinion. Thank God saner minds
are gradually prevailing now with lots of them reiterating hitherto unpopular
positions I had held.
Where
on earth could you have someone with the record of Amie Bensouda serving as
Lead Counsel in any proper legal or quasi-legal setting, dealing with matters
that have her own fingerprints deeply embedded? And then you come to see Essa
Faal use a national platform to settle scores in the open; clearly taking
positions that favour his ‘constituency’!
Without
a doubt, the TRRC deserves criticism but no one should threaten the institution
and its staff with closure or banning or any thing close to that. Such
utterances and the threat to expel people with different religious beliefs from
the country are actually the main reasons why I rushed to dissociate myself
from the whatsap audio for which Mr. Jallow and his likes are berating me. Yet
TRRC can and should do better.
A
case in point was the testimony received by the commission on the plight of the
media fraternity under the Jammeh regime. The GPU’ S.G came and presented an
impressive record of how his people suffered.
Yet
the TRRC never lifted a finger to show the world how the same press that was a
victim was also a villain in many ways. There are thousands of Gambians who
suffered because of professional misconduct, and someimtes outright malicious
conduct, of the press during the Jammeh era; but all these things were swept
under the carpet during these proceedings. Now wonder we are already seeing
clear repetitions of the errors of the past in the operations all four estates
of our state architecture.
But
how can we fully account for the errors of the past and make proper
recommendations for enlightened action when the TRRC’s Executive Secretary is
himself conflicted? A particular witness at the TRRC made adverse mention of
the newspaper that was being rung by the TRRC’s Executive Secretary back in the
days but I am yet to hear the TRRC summon their Executive Secretary to testify.
Are
we not shortchanging future generations of Gambians and the victims in
particular by marring the TRRC’s proceedings with palpable bias?
Indeed
I am not beyond reproach regarding the context of all I have stated in this
essay. But I am man enough to admit my errors and to know that we need to rise
above the levels we are condemning the past regime for. I have acted (in the
past) in ways and manners below the highest standards expected of me, albeit
under the most insidious levels of coercion
but I have decided that “Never Again” should not be a mere slogan on tv
and banners.
We
must live the ethos of “Never Again” as
a nation and the best way to ensure that reality is to maintain and sustain
high standards based on fair play. Mediocrity is a disease that will gnaw at
the very fabric of our society and bring us down, as a nation, into the abyss.
We must strive to rise up to new levels of professionalism and fair play if
indeed we are serious with the concept of “New Gambia”.
Should
we not pitch for higher standards in this country? Can’t we for once embark on
a national day of fasting and repentance and to take a new covenant to raise
the bar and maintain decent and respectable standards in our country?
A
lot of water has passed under the bridge and we know for sure that our
development partners have lost hope in the “New Gambia Project” as evidenced by
their palpable snubbing of the pledges they made towards the implementation of
our national development plan. Yet all is not lost. We can decide to sanitise
our transition and pump in some much-needed Adrenalin for a new take-off based
on self-reliance, national unity and genuine reconciliation.
God
bless The Gambia.
Momodou
Sabally
Former
Presidential Affairs Minister, S.G and Head of the Civil Service.
