Bakary Sanyang opened the scores for Colley Stars in the first half.
Delmass Jatta restored parity for Kanifing East in the stoppage time.
Kanifing East still occupy second-place on the country's Second Tier table with 45 points after twenty-five league outings.
Colley Stars sit top-spot on the Second Division League table with 51 points in twenty-five league matches.
Meanwhile, Kanifing East drew 1-1 with Colley Stars in the first round of the country's Second Tier.
