Yankuba Sisawo opened the scores for Bafuloto United FC after 41 seconds.
Black Stars FC reacted for an equaliser and levelled matters through Modou Lamin Sonko in the stoppage time thus the match ended 1-1.
This pushed the match into post-match penalty shootouts, which ended 4-3 in favour of Bafuloto United FC.
The victory earned Bafuloto FC a place in the second round of the Brikama nawettan qualifiers.
The defeat saw Black Stars FC out of the Brikama wet season biggest football festivity qualifiers.
Black Stars FC will now hang their boots until next year after exit from the Brikama nawettan qualifiers.
