In Musa Yalli Batchilly’s trial, defence takes prosecution witness to task

Dec 29, 2020, 12:20 PM | Article By: Dawda Faye

Defence Counsel Kijera, representing Musa Yalli Batchilly, the secretary general of Gambia Action Party (GAP), who is charged with obtaining money by false pretence and fraud, recently challenged the third prosecution witness by cross-examining him to test his credibility before Principal Magistrate Isatou Janneh-Njie of the Kanifing Magistrates’ Court.

Lawyer Kijera asked the witness, Mr. Sowe, an investigating officer, whether he prepared the investigation report. He answered in the positive.

He was also asked whether he prepared the charge of obtaining money by false pretence and what were the reasons. In response, the witness told the court that the accused admitted that the house belongs to one Salifu Batchilly. He was questioned whether he recorded this in the statement, and he answered in the positive. At this juncture, the defence counsel requested for the statement which was given to him. He then showed it to the witness to read out where the accused admitted that the property belongs to Salifu Batchilly. He then read out the statement.

“Did you confirm from Salifu Batchilly that he owns the house?” he was asked.

“Salifu was not within the country, and there was no means to get to him,” he responded. It was put to him that the investigation was biased, and that if the investigation was not biased, the witness would have confirmed from Salifu. Mr. Sowe answered that it was not biased.

He was asked who reported the matter to the police. In response, he told the court that Modou Mbye, the complainant’s brother, acted on behalf of his sister when he reported the matter to the police. It was put to him that he was not speaking the truth because there was no document given to him to show that Modou Mbye reported the matter on behalf of his sister. He maintained that Modou Mbye did so.    

“You said there was an agreement between the complainant and the accused,” he was reminded.

“Yes, there was,” he replied.

He was further challenged that as an investigator, why he did say that the accused acted under false pretence before being able to confirm from the owner, and that he had personalised the case.  He denied it.

“Do you know that prosecution is the last resort for a lead investigator?” he was asked.

“Yes, but the accused made promises which he never fulfilled, though there was enough time,” he said.

It was then put to him that the complainant used him to implicate the accused, which he denied. He was again asked whether he knew the consequences of taking an oath on the Qur’an. But this did not go down well with the prosecuting officer, Superintendent Manga, who objected and said that the question asked by the defence counsel was not relevant. He further stated that asking the witness whether he knew the consequences of taking an oath on the Qur’an or whether he is a Muslim was irrelevant because they were not in a mosque but in a court of law.

The case continues.       

Read Other Articles In Headlines
Stop Domestic Violence
Special courts for domestic violence to be established
Aug 20, 2021, 2:54 PM

The Ministry of Gender, Children and Social Welfare is gearing-up to establish special court for domestic violence as the fight against Female Genital Mutilation/Cutting (FGM/C) and Gender Based Violence among other negative issues affecting women and girls intensifies in the country

Beakanyang v5
URR governor applauds Beakanyang
Mar 18, 2021, 1:52 PM

The governor of URR has described Beakanyang organization as very credible and hailed the civil society organisation for empowering communities in the region.

UDP v2
Police intercept UDP vehicle with suspected cannabis 
Apr 19, 2021, 11:40 AM

Security patrol taskforce comprising different security units have intercepted a vehicle belonging to the opposition United Democratic Party (UDP) with some suspected cannabis, as the country’s security operatives intensified “Operation Zero Crime”, The Point has been reliably informed.

SEN closed amid feeding challenges
Feb 7, 2022, 11:58 AM

The School for Enrolled Nurses and Midwives (SEN) in Bansang informed its students and staff that all activities including learning have been ceased effective 4 February 2020 till further notice due to feeding difficulties.