Defense says Yankuba has no case to answer

May 29, 2020, 11:34 AM | Article By: Dawda Faye

Defense Counsel Sissoho yesterday told the High Court in Banjul before Justice Ebrima Jaiteh that Yankuba Tourya, who is facing a murder charge, has no case to answer.

This followed the announcement of the closure of the prosecution case by the state counsel, A.M. Yusuf.

Counsel Sissoho stated that he was making a no-case submission on behalf of the accused under Section 7 (d) of the constitution and Section 166 of the Criminal Procedure Code. He said that by the bill of indictment dated 20th July, 2019, the accused is charged with a single count of murder contrary to Section 187 of the Criminal Code.

He noted that the particulars of offence indicated that Koro Ceesay was beaten with a pestle-like object and other dangerous weapon. He added that the prosecution had called their witnesses and tendered three sets of documents, further stating that they also tendered a photocopy of an autopsy prepared by Dr. Oldfield. “This is the case of the prosecution in support of the charge of murder,” he told the court.

He was asked whether the prosecution had established a prima facie case against the accused to warrant him to open his defense. He submitted that there are two conditions in testing a prima facie case. “One is when there is no evidence to prove an essential element. Two, if the evidence is so weak and discredited,” he answered.

He added that the prosecution should prove the cause of death and that the accused is a murderer and the commission of the accused was unlawful. “From PW 1 to PW 6, there is no proof that Koro Ceesay is dead. PW 9 also testified that he saw Koro Ceesay a week before the 3rd June, 1995,” he told the court.

He argued that the scientific and the best conclusive proof of death is the autopsy report, adding that exhibits P3 and P3 (A) are the same autopsy report which was the photocopy and the original. He further stated that the said exhibits indicated that Koro Ceesay was presumed dead.

“No DNA test was carried out. No evidence was led by PW 9 that the remains were kept to do DNA test. Excluding PW 6, all the witnesses never saw the deceased with the accused. PW 2 and PW 3 confirmed that fact.  PW 9, who is a relative of the deceased, spoke highly of the accused. The evidence of PW 1, PW 2, PW 5, PW 7, PW 8 and PW 9 are not relevant and the witnesses wasted the time of the court. Their evidence has no value,” Counsel Sissoho submitted.

He argued that the second element of the case was to show that the act of the accused caused the death of Koro Ceesay. “No stick, no knife, no weapon was tendered before the court to connect the accused to the ownership of that weapon. They have to prove that there was a weapon used to kill Koro Ceesay. The best evidence is to determine whether the weapon was capable to harm the deceased,” he stated.

He noted that the evidence- in-chief of PW7, Chief Momodou Bojang, was very important. He argued that no evidence had been led to prove that the persons mentioned by Chief Momodou Bojang in his evidence are alive. “Dr. Badjan, the pathologist, only pinched from a record and not in detail. There is no deceased. In the absence of substantial evidence, the accused should be set free. Alagie Kanyi confirmed that between 8 p.m. upwards he was at Cape Point and was also at the residence of the accused. From 4 p.m. Friday 23rd June, 1995 till 1 a.m. and on Saturday PW 2, PW3 and PW 4 confirmed that they were in the residence of the accused at various times and the accused and his family were in his house,” Sissoho told the court.

He submitted that PW2, 3 and 4 gave inconsistent statements with that of Alagie Kanyi, adding that none of them saw Alagie Kanyi at the residence of the accused. He stated that PW 2, 3 and 4 placed the accused at State House in Banjul, further noting that the prosecution witnesses contradicted one another, and the doubt should be resolved in favour of the accused. “The evidence of murder is missing,” he said.

He stated that Alagie Kanyi did not tell the court who killed Koro Ceesay, noting further that Alagie Kanyi told the court that Edward Singhateh hit Koro Ceesay from the back and he died. “It was also Alagie Kanyi who said that all of them hit Koro Ceesay which caused his death. The failure of the accused to testify at the TRRC brought the anger,” Counsel Sissoho declared.

He said that Mr. Kanyi had lied to the court and there was no material evidence before the court, stating that there was no case to answer. He subsequently urged the court to acquit and discharge the accused.

The matter was adjourned to the 2nd June, 2020, for the prosecution to reply.

Read Other Articles In Headlines
Sukuta Salagi press conference
Gov’t defends demolition of Sukuta-Salagi homes
Jun 4, 2020, 10:43 AM

The Gambia government through the Ministry of Lands and Regional Governments has defended its action in demolishing built and under-construction homes in Salaji which sparked a row between people of Sukuta and Department of Physical Planning.

Amir baba Trawally
Amir Trawally calls for unity as he delivers Eid-ul-Fitr message
May 27, 2020, 12:44 PM

All praise belongs to Allah Almighty Who has blessed us with the Holy Month of Ramadan and has enabled us to come to the end of this year’s Ramadan.

‘I was aware that Edward was vice chairman of AFPRC’
Jun 25, 2020, 11:18 AM

Awa Minteh, first defence witness in Yankuba’s trial, yesterday told the High Court in Banjul before Justice Ebrima Jaiteh that she was aware that Edward Singhateh was the Vice Chairman of AFPRC as from 1995, and this was all over the media.

Momodou and Gibba
Ward councilor requests police chief to address Gunjur Police Station mobility constraint
May 21, 2020, 12:05 PM

Gunjur Ward councilor, Momodou Charreh Jibba has written to the Inspector General of Police challenging him to address the mobility constraint that is currently slowing the effective execution of the work of the police at the Gunjur Police Station.

Minister Kinteh underscores role of women in national development
Jul 1, 2020, 11:13 AM

The minister for Women, Children and Social Welfare, Fatou Kinteh has underscored the role and contribution of women in national development, stating that the country cannot develop without empowering the women.

Basirou Sene
2nd phase beneficiaries of Senegalese gov’t assistance to receive 50,000 CFA each
May 15, 2020, 11:49 AM

Senegalese ambassador to The Gambia, Hon. Bassirou Sene has confirmed that each beneficiary of the second phase in The Gambia will receive 50,000 CFA from the Senegalese government as assistance to the Diaspora.

Nancy Ceesay and Bah
Unveiling of the 1946 Air crash memorial plaque at Arch 22
Jul 1, 2020, 11:01 AM

Press release : Last year on 7 September, the British High Commission organised a small ceremony at the Jeshwang cemetery to commemorate those who lost their lives in the 1946 air crash.

NAWEC 1 v2
Electrocution kills 2 in Banjul
Jun 18, 2020, 12:12 PM

Two people are reported to have died as a result of being electrocuted in Banjul on Monday, The Point has been reliably informed.