Both sides came for victory to sail to the final of the Kombo South District football tournament but normal time failed to produce a winner.
This pushed the match into post-match penalty shootouts, which ended 5-4 in favour of Tujereng.
The defeat saw Nyofelleh out of the Kombo South District football tournament.
Nyofelleh will now hang their boots until next year after their exit from the Kombo South District football tournament.
