Justice Ebrima Jaiteh of the High Court has granted plaintiff Abubacarr Jawara leave to adduce evidence in rebuttal after the defence closed its case, ruling that closure alone does not bar material rebuttal evidence.
The application was made orally by Jawara's counsel, I. Drameh, under Order XXXV, Rule 8. Jawara sought to tender audio recordings said to contradict answers given by second defendant Saihou Drammeh during cross-examination.
Both sides had already closed their cases. Drammeh had denied several matters put to him. Counsel Drameh argued the recordings would show those denials were untrue on material issues, and that copies would be provided in advance.
Counsel for first defendant Kaddijah Kebbeh, K. Jallow, did not object. Counsel for Drammeh, Badou S. M. Conteh, opposed the application, arguing Jawara should not be allowed to introduce further evidence after the defence had closed. He said he would accept service if directed, while maintaining his objection.
Justice Jaiteh framed four issues for determination: whether leave could be sought under Rules 8 and 9; whether the recordings could qualify as admissible rebuttal rather than an attempt to reopen the case; whether granting leave would cause prejudice; and whether justice favoured granting leave with safeguards.
He held that Rule 8 allows the party beginning to reply generally where the opposing party has called evidence. Rule 9 contemplates evidence in reply being tendered and allowed, subject to the court's permission and admissibility rules.
Citing Rogers v Manley (1880) and the persuasive Jamaican decision in Lilieth Douglas v Errol Francis, he said rebuttal may be admitted to explain, contradict or answer material defence evidence. It must not be used to cure omissions or to contradict purely collateral answers.
Justice Jaiteh stressed that the recordings had not yet been tendered, examined or authenticated. The ruling, he said, does not establish that Drammeh gave false evidence or that the recordings contradict his testimony.
On prejudice, he held that closure alone does not prove injustice. Fairness, he said, could be secured through advance disclosure, cross-examination, and the right to challenge admissibility.
The application was therefore granted subject to conditions.
Jawara must serve complete copies on both Kebbeh and Drammeh before the next hearing date, and file an identical copy with the Registrar, together with a schedule identifying the portions relied upon and the testimony they are intended to rebut. Filing alone is not admission.
At the next hearing, Jawara must lay a foundation through a competent witness and establish relevance, authenticity and admissibility under the Evidence Act, 1994, and section 188 of the Information and Communications Act, 2009. Non-English recordings require a verified English transcription.
The defendants may object to admissibility or relevance, and if admitted, may cross-examine and seek recall or responsive evidence.
The matter was adjourned for tendering.