#Opinion

Economywatch - With Osman Kargbo & Tedla E. Khan : Sharia and Succession: Navigating Intergenerational Wealth Transition in The Gambia

May 14, 2024, 10:53 AM | Article By: Tedla E. Khan

Over the next two decades, an estimated $68 trillion will transition from Baby Boomers to Gen X and Millennial heirs. This global phenomenon known as the "Great Wealth Transfer" is particularly relevant in The Gambia. While the magnitude of domestic wealth transfer will be a fraction of global averages, this shift of wealth necessitates not only financial management skills but also a transfer of knowledge to navigate newfound assets effectively.

In The Gambia, where over 90% of the population is Muslim, Sharia Law governs certain aspects of life, including inheritance and wealth transfer, understanding the dynamics of this system is crucial for individuals and families involved in estate planning.

This article delves into the nuances of intergenerational wealth transfer within the framework of Sharia Law, and practical implications in The Gambia.

Transition to Sharia Law in The Gambia

The transition to Sharia Law in The Gambia, as established by constitutional provisions like S.137(1) of the 1997 Constitution, marked a significant shift in the legal framework governing matters of marriage, divorce, and inheritance. This transition resulted in the establishment of the Cadi Court, replacing the Mohammedan Courts and bringing substantial changes to estate planning practices.

This is notable because most Gambians – particularly those in the diaspora – who are generating and transferring this wealth may not be aware of the intricacies of Sharia Law and how it impacts asset distribution.  According to recent studies, approximately 60% of estates are contested in The Gambia, which is 2.5x higher than probated wills in the United States, highlighting the need for better estate planning practices.

Consequences of Sharia Law Transition

One of the key consequences of this transition is the restriction on freedom of testation. Under Sharia Law, individuals have limited autonomy to distribute their estates freely, as shares for heirs are prescribed based on familial relationships.

Moreover, Islamic inheritance laws may differ significantly from civil law, particularly concerning gender parity in asset distribution. In certain contexts, men and women may receive unequal shares under Sharia Law, adding another layer of complexity to intergenerational wealth transfer strategies.

Sharia Law also introduces the concept of Faraid distribution, which specifies specific shares for heirs, often overriding the provisions of a will. However, within this framework, individuals can utilize "wasiyyah" to allocate up to one-third of their estate beyond the prescribed shares, promoting a more orderly and flexible asset transfer process.

When Does Sharia Law Apply

The impact of these legal changes is primarily felt by Muslims, as S.137(4) of the Constitution restricts the application of Sharia Law to matters of marriage, divorce, and inheritance involving Muslim individuals.

Simply put, if the wealth owner is Muslim at the time of death, then Sharia law applies, if invoked, regardless of the religious orientation of the next of kin.

This jurisdictional limitation directly affects Muslims' estate planning decisions and asset transfer strategies, requiring them to navigate the intricacies of Sharia Law while ensuring compliance with legal requirements.

Impact of Wealth Destruction on the Economy and Society

Improper wealth transfer mechanisms, such as those that have historically led to the destruction of great Gambian businesses, can have devastating effects on the economy. These businesses, which are essential drivers of wealth, job creation, and GDP growth, serve as pillars of the economy, and their destruction can hinder economic progress and stability.

Approximately 50 - 60% of GDP is generated by medium- and large-size enterprises, according to The Gambia Chamber of Commerce and Industry (GCCI), with two-thirds of these companies being single- or multi-family owned. Thus, such disruptions in intergenerational wealth transfer in these companies can significantly handicap the economy's ability to thrive and grow sustainably.

However, properly managed wealth transfer allows for the infusion of capital into key sectors of the economy, with studies showing that inheritors of wealth are more likely to invest in entrepreneurial ventures, innovation, and sustainable practices.  

Estate Planning & Securing the Bag for Future Generations

Regardless of the prevailing legal framework (i.e., Sharia or Civil), effective intergenerational wealth transfer requires one to face one’s mortality, hire professional advisors, and plan – regardless of how young one may be. A comprehensive approach to estate planning is the only way to preserve one’s legacy and ensure a smooth asset transfer across generations.

One crucial aspect is structuring assets in alignment with Sharia principles. This involves utilizing deeds of gifts, trusts and foundations strategically to facilitate orderly wealth transfer while adhering to Islamic guidelines. By structuring assets appropriately, individuals can navigate the complexities of Sharia Law and ensure that their assets are distributed according to their wishes and religious beliefs.

Another consideration is understanding the variations in Islamic wealth transfer taxation across different jurisdictions. This knowledge is essential for effective estate planning, as tax implications can significantly impact the distribution of assets to future generations. According to experts, disputes over Sharia-compliant inheritance are not uncommon, especially in regions where Sharia law governs estate matters.

Education and awareness play a vital role in empowering individuals to navigate Shariah principles effectively in estate planning. Providing individuals with knowledge about Sharia Law and its implications for asset transfer allows them to make informed decisions that align with their religious beliefs and legal obligations. This education can include understanding Faraid distribution, "wasiyyah" provisions, and other relevant aspects of Islamic inheritance laws.

Conclusion

The only two things in life that are guaranteed are – death and taxes. It is best to plan for both. Through strategic planning and legal compliance, individuals can secure their legacies while contributing to a thriving economy and a more equitable society in The Gambia.