PRAYER CARRYING AND HOLDING A CHILD DURING THE SALAH

Friday, November 16, 2018

Abu Qatadah reports that the Prophet Sallallahu alehi wasallam was offering Salah and Umamah Bint Zainab was on his neck [shoulder]. When he performed ruku’, he put her down, and when he got up from his sajdah, he would place her back on his neck. ‘Amr inquired during which Salah this happened. Ibn Juraij said that it is related from Zaid ibn Abu ‘Atab from ‘Amr ibn Salim that this happened in the Morning Prayer. This is related by Ahmad, anNasa’i, and others. Al-Fakihani comments: “The purpose behind the action of the Prophet of carrying Umamah in the Salah was to set an example before the Arabs who considered having daughters and carrying them around as something bad or shameful. The Prophet Sallallahu alehi wasallam acted differently from them, and carried a girl on his neck in the prayer, and making something clear by example is much more effective than a mere precept.” ‘Abdullah ibn Shidad relates that his father said: “The Messenger of Allah came to us either during the noon or afternoon prayers and he was carrying Hassan or Hussain. The Prophet proceeded to the front and put him down and made the takbir for the Salah. During the Salah, he made a long Sajdah. I raised my head and saw the child on the back of the Messenger of Allah while he was in Sajdah. I returned to my Sajdah. When the Messenger of Allah finished the Salah, the people said to him: ‘O Messenger of Allah, you prostrated during your Salah so long that we suspected you were thinking about some matter or you were receiving some revelation.’ He said: ‘None of that happened but my son was resting and I hated to rush him until he had finished what he desired.”’ This is related by Ahmad, an-Nasa’i, and AL Hakim.

An-Nawawi observes that this, according to the opinion of ash-Shaf’i and those who agree with him, points to the permissibility of carrying or holding a young child, male or female, or any pure animal during an obligatory prayer, and that it is permissible for both the imam and the followers. The companions of Malik say that the permissibility is only for voluntary prayers and not for obligatory prayers. This interpretation is incorrect as it is clear that the Prophet was leading one of the obligatory prayers, and as stated earlier it was the fajr prayer. Some followers of Malik claim that its permissibility has been abrogated, while others say it was only permissible for the Prophet, and yet others hold that it was due to some necessity. All of this is wrong and to be rejected as there is no proof for any of it or any necessity. The authentic hadith clearly states that it is permissible and there is nothing in that ruling which contradicts any basic principle of the shari’ah as a human being is pure and what is in his/her abdomen is not relevant in this regard, as it remains within the stomach, its natural receptacle. Also, the clothing of a child is considered pure and the shari’ah is quite explicit on this point. Actions during the Salah do not invalidate it if they are minor or few or dispersed. The fact that the Prophet Sallallahu alehi wasallam did this is an exposition of its permissibility, and this argument is built upon the principle which we have mentioned before. This refutes what Abu Sulaiman al-Khattabi says, namely, that the Prophet did not carry the child intentionally but the child was holding onto the Prophet, and when he stood the child remained with him. He said: “Do not think that he held him again intentionally as that would be too much action and would distract the heart. If a curtain distracted him, how could [the child] not distract him?” This statement by al-Khattabi, May Allah have mercy on him, is incorrect and to be rejected. Among the things that refute it are the statements in Sahih Muslim, “when he stood, he carried him.” And, “when he got up from his Sajdah, he would return [the child to his place].” Further refutations are derived from a version other than Sahih Muslim, “He came to us while carrying Umamah and prayed...” Concerning the ruling about the curtain, it distracts the heart without there being any benefit to it. Concerning carrying Umamah, we are not convinced that it distracts the heart, and even if it does, it is allowed due to its benefit and the principles that we have mentioned. The source of that preoccupation is that benefit, which differs from the incident concerning the curtain. Thus, the correct position is that the hadith is a clear exposition that it is permissible to carry a child in Salah and this will continue to be part of the Islamic law until the Day of Judgment. And Allah knows best.

RETURNING A GREETING BY A MOTION 

The one in Salah who is greeted or spoken to my reply to the one who greets or speaks to him by making some motion. Jabir said: “The Messenger of Allah sent me somewhere while he was going to the tribe of Mustaliq. I came to him and he was praying while on the back of his camel. [When] I spoke to him; he and Zubair motioned with their hands. I heard him reciting and saw him gesturing with his head. When he finished, he said: ‘What have you done about the thing I sent you for? Nothing kept me from talking to you save that I was in Salah.’” This is related by Ahmad and Muslim. ‘Abdullah ibn ‘Umar narrates that Suhaib said: “I passed by the Messenger of Allah while he was offering Salah. I greeted him and he responded to me by only signaling.” ‘Abdullah said: “The only thing that I know is that he said he signaled to him with his finger.” This is related by Ahmad and by atTirmizhi. The latter calls it Sahih. ‘Abdullah ibn ‘Umar says: “I asked Suhaib: ‘How did the Messenger of Allah respond to the people when they greeted him while he was praying?’ He said: ‘He would signal to them with his hand.’” This is related by Ahmad, at-Tirmizhi, Abu Dawud, an-Nasa’i, and Ibn Majah. Anas says that the Prophet would signal while offering Salah. This is related by Ahmad, Abu Dawud, and Ibn Khuzaimah and its isnad is Sahih. The same applies to signaling with one’s finger or hand or by nodding the head. All of these actions have been related from the Prophet Sallallahu alehi wasallam.

SAYING SUBHANALLAH AND CLAPPING 

It is allowed for men to say subhanallah and for women to clap if there is some need to do so (such as alerting the imam to a mistake or informing someone that he or she may enter the room or to warn a blind person, and so on). Sahl ibn SA’d asSa’di relates that the Prophet said: “If someone is faced with something during the Salah, he should say ‘Subhanallah.’ Clapping is for the women and saying Subhanallah is for the men.” This is related by Ahmad, Abu Dawud, and an-Nasa’i.

CORRECTING THE IMAM’S MISTAKE 

If the imam forgets a verse, it is permissible for a follower to remind him of it, regardless of whether the recitation is a part of the obligatory recitation or not. Ibn ‘Umar reports that the Messenger of Allah prayed and had some confusion in his recitation. When he finished, he said to ‘Umar: “Were you present with us [during the prayer]?” He replied: “Yes.” So, the Prophet Sallallahu alehi wasallam asked him: “What prevented you from correcting me?” This is related by Abu Dawud and others and its narrators are trustworthy.

PRAISING ALLAH WHEN ONE SNEEZES OR RECALLS TO MIND A BLESSING 

Rifa’ah ibn Rafi’ relates: “I prayed behind the Messenger of Allah, and I sneezed and said, ‘Praise be to Allah, a great deal of praise, beautiful and blessed, as our Lord loves and is pleased with.’ [Afterward,] the Messenger of Allah asked: ‘Who spoke during the Salah?’ No one said anything. He asked again, and no one said anything. He asked again, and I said: ‘It was I, O Messenger of Allah!’ He then said: ‘By the One in whose hand is Muhammad’s soul, thirty some odd angels raced to get that phrase to raise it [to the Lord].’” This is related by an-Nasa’i and at-Tirmizhi, and by al-Bukhari with a different wording.

PROSTRATING UPON ONE’S CLOTHING OR HEADDRESS DUE TO SOME EXCUSE 

Ibn ‘Abbas reports that the Messenger of Allah prayed in one garment and covered his face with a portion of it to avoid the heat or coldness of the ground. This is related by Ahmad with a Sahih isnad chain). It is disliked if it is done without any genuine reason.

A summary of other acts which are permissible during the prayer 

Ibn al-Qayyim has summarized some of the acts which are permissible during the Salah and which the Prophet Sallallahu alehi wasallam used to perform at times. He writes:

  To Be Continued